Favre, Collie and the non-discriminating concussion

By Sunday, January 9, 2011 9 No tags Permalink

From a 41 year old in his 20th season to a 25 year old in his 2nd. The secret to concussion prevention hasn’t been found in  experience, age, athleticism or stubbornness.

Awareness won’t eliminate concussions either, but it will help to reduce the likelihood of longer-term brain injury. First concussion: bad, second concussion: exponentially worse. Austin Collie, 25, wide receiver for the Indianapolis Colts, finished his 2nd season on week 15. Brett Favre, 41, quarterback for the Minnesota Vikings, finished his 20th season and ended his consecutive start streak at 297 games, also finished his season on week 15.

Favre’s streak ended on week 13 due to a shoulder injury, severe enough to end his ironman streak that had so many commentators competing to laud him. A common praise was for his child-like enthusiasm for the game even in his 20th season in the NFL (often given as a reason for his ironman streak). Ironically, that child-like enthusiasm may also be the reason he finally ends his career.  (Granted, it won’t be long into the 2011 regular season that he turns 42 and he had a statistically poor season, but the man’s tendency to stick around is legendary.) Paying no attention to logic, he came into the week 15 game – if for no other reason than to prove to himself that he could – and in the second quarter his season and his career (or so he says now) came to an end following a concussion that even Favre, in all of his stubbornness, could recognize was serious enough to prevent him from playing in the Vikings final two games.

But, he’s 42, an antique in the NFL. Austin Collie is only 25, in only his second season. Nevertheless, he too was out in week 15 after his second concussion of the season. Earlier in the season, Collie missed 3 straight games due to concussion, then in his first game back, suffered another concussion, ending his season with longer-lasting effects on his career. Collie’s situation should not be glossed over. A young, talented receiver with two brain injuries in a matter of weeks. The silver lining may be the timing of the second concussion – since it happened toward the end of the season and since the Colts lost their first round playoff game, he can take more time to recover before he feels pressure to play at the beginning of the season.

Whether it’s an experienced quarterback seemingly immune to injury, or a receiver two years into his career, head injuries in football don’t discriminate. Their prevalence in contact sports is obvious. Concussions should be seen not as a ‘risk’ in contact sports and not quite an inevitability either, but is important that they be recognized as part of the game that cannot be ignored.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *